Why young talent should join the plastic revolution
The future of the plastics industry hinges on a shift to a circular business model and the recruitment of the brightest and the best young people, Lucrèce Foufopoulos says in an I...
Sustainability
An ESG primer for business leaders
ESG is a frequently cited business principle that is growing rapidly in importance. Recently PwC announced plans to invest $12bn to create 100,000 new jobs in order to help its clients understand, adopt and achieve ESG goals.
Yet ESG is not always well understood and it is plagued by pervasive myths, such as the idea that it is only relevant for polluting industries, or the notion that it is just a flavor of Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR).
A stronger understanding of ESG (what ESG is, imperative for integrating ESG into business thinking and what it can do for your business) will go a long way in unlocking value for businesses, customers and communities.
The ABCs of ESG
ESG isn’t a feel-good initiative, and it isn’t synonymous with sustainable investing, CSR or socially responsible investing. ESG is part of the impact investing spectrum and also factors in ethical considerations to take environmental, social and governance factors into account alongside financial factors in the investment decision-making process.
Let’s look at each part of ESG.
Environment (E) focuses on the energy a business consumes and the waste it discharges. It also takes into account the resources that the business draws from the planet, and the consequences for living beings (not just humans) as a result of the draw on those resources. While carbon emissions, greenhouse gas and climate change are top of mind, it is important to understand that businesses use energy and natural resources and in doing so affect our environment.
Social (S) focuses on the quality of relationships businesses foster with employees, customers, vendors, partner institutions, and communities where they operate. S includes employee relations and diversity and inclusion. It underscores that every business operates within a broader, diverse society.
Governance (G) addresses the internal system of guiding principles, practices, controls, and procedures businesses adopt to self-govern, make effective decisions, comply with the law, and meet stakeholders needs.
What is at stake for businesses?
ESG issues are increasingly having an impact on the corporate balance sheet. When done right the payoffs are high, but when mistakes are made the reputational risks and pitfalls can be debilitating.
Businesses that have an integrated ESG orientation can increase shareholder value by creating brand preference; proactively manage risks, including reputation; avoiding regulatory action; and gaining preferential access to new markets.
Businesses that improve employee conditions, including safety and well-being, enhance diversity, contribute to their communities, and stand for sustainable environmental practices that strengthen their brand favorability. Millennials in particular prefer to be associated as employees, consumers and investors with companies that are good corporate actors, and they reward those businesses with their loyalty.
Businesses and boards also have to be aware of the negative consequences of not addressing ESG risks, some of which can materialize quite suddenly.
Here are some examples:
The upside of managing ESG risks and converting them into opportunities
3M has saved $2.2bn since introducing its “pollution prevention pays” (3Ps) program in 1975. The company prevents pollution upstream by reformulating products, improving manufacturing processes, redesigning equipment, and recycling and reusing production waste.
Starbucks, which had a challenging time gaining traction in China, leveraged the S in ESG effectively by offering healthcare to employee parents. Starbuck’s sales skyrocketed.
Unilever developed Sunlight, a brand of dishwashing liquid that uses much less water than other brands. Sales of Sunlight outpaced other products in that category by more than 20%.
Costco has introduced new environmental initiatives such as compostable coffee pods in its warehouses, a new policy regarding the use of chemicals, and a commitment to install solar panels at its stores. The company is also known for treating their employees well, offering a minimum wage of $15 an hour as well as awesome benefits. Having embraced and integrated ESG factors, Costco is better positioned for growth in the long run and less likely to be plagued by controversy or scandals.
Negative consequences from not managing ESG risks
The Wall Street Journal called PG&E “the first climate-change bankruptcy”. PG&E’s fall was fast and steep after it was engulfed by liabilities resulting from Californian wildfires potentially caused by its power lines. In October 2018, the company’s market capitalization was $25bn. In January 2019 it was removed from the S&P 500 when its value tumbled to below $4bn and its shares fell to their lowest level since 1972. PG&E’s case highlights the potential for climate change to damage company assets and cause a mushrooming of liabilities as an emerging enterprise risk, which needs to be proactively managed.
Wells Fargo continues to deal with the overhang of its 2016 customer-account scandal (in which it opened millions of fee-paying accounts without the consent of its customers). This highlighted weaknesses in governance and inadequate risk-management systems, and the company had its growth capped by regulators as a result. This came on top of the $100m in fines by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.
The Wells Fargo case and the recent Boeing 737 Max scandal are reminders that governance failures can quickly bring successful and storied brands to their knees.
How to integrate ESG into corporate strategy
For ESG to be sustainable and value creating in the long run, relevant ESG themes need to be integrated with business goals:
- Grow revenue
- Reduce cost
- Minimize regulatory and legal risks
- Improve employee productivity
- Optimize capital allocation
And specific ESG actions can be deployed to drive value in each of these areas:
Pick goals that meet the needs of the stakeholders and businesses, and proactively integrate the relevant ESG themes and key issues into your Enterprise Risk Management (ERM) process.
ESG factors are often deemed immaterial or expected to occur over the long term. Don’t bet on it. ESG risks should be assessed, including using a materiality lens to consider whether and when the issues surface and how that would impact (severity scale) business performance.
The Nestle stakeholder relevance and materiality matrix is a helpful way to organize thinking.
Key questions to ask as board director and business leader
Is ESG integrated into our corporate strategy? Have we identified and set compelling sustainability targets and goals that resonate with our stakeholders’ interests? How do sustainability targets and goals compare to those of competitors?
How are our ESG story and sustainability targets and goals communicated internally and externally? What is the level of buy-in within the organization? Are adequate resources and skills in place to achieve those targets and goals?
How best to integrate ESG targets and goals with financial reporting? Are we providing meaningful updates to investors and stakeholders via financial reports, disclosures, quarterly earnings calls and investor roadshows?
What reporting framework (see Box) have we adopted, and why? What frameworks are our competitors using? What are the recommended industry frameworks? How do we avoid “greenwashing”?
What are the ESG risks facing the organization, and how well are they being tracked and managed as part of Enterprise Risk Management? How are these risks communicated in the public disclosures?
What accountabilities and incentives are in place to deliver on ESG goals and targets?
As a business leader you have an opportunity to shape your organization’s mindset to expand beyond shareholder orientation to stakeholder orientation. Identify relevant ESG themes. Communicate the why and how to internal and external stakeholders. Integrate ESG into business strategy, risk management and operational processes. Track and share progress. By doing so, foster a triple bottom line orientation (people, planet, profit) that creates a brighter and sustainable future for generations to come.
BOX – ESG REPORTING FRAMEWORKS AND RATINGS
FRAMEWORKS FOR DISCLOSURES AND REPORTING
There is no common standard yet for ESG disclosures and reporting, so businesses have to be creative in blending multiple frameworks in order to better meet their needs. The various ESG frameworks follow different methodologies, resulting in many scoring systems and data interpretations.
Some of the popular frameworks are
GRI (Global Reporting Initiative)
GRI was launched in 1997 based on Ceres (formerly Coalition for Environmentally Responsible Economies) principles for responsible environmental conduct with endorsements from Tellus Institute, The United Nations Environment Program (UNEP), U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). The framework was then expanded to include social, economic and governance issues. Today, several stakeholders, including investors, businesses and governments, use the GRI Sustainability Reporting Standards to communicate on a range of impacts, including climate change, human rights, governance and social well-being.
SASB (Sustainability Accounting Standards Board)
SASB was launched in 2011 to develop standards to better align “sustainability fundamentals” with “financial fundamentals” with the goal of helping investors efficiently compare business performance on social and environmental issues in order to allocate capital to the most sustainable outcomes. The Harvard Initiative for Responsible Investments was also actively involved in shaping this initiative. SASB’s framework focuses on “financially material information” and complements other frameworks including GRI, the Carbon Disclosure Project, International Integrated Reporting Council and Taskforce for Climate-related Financial Disclosures.
TCFD (Taskforce for Climate-related Financial Disclosures)
The Financial Stability Board established the TCFD in 2015 at the request of the G20. TCFD’s disclosure framework enables businesses to report on their climate-related financial risks to investors, lenders, insurers and others. TCFD covers physical, liability and transition risks.
CDP (Carbon Disclosure Project)
Launched in 2000 to enable global economic system to operate within sustainable environmental boundaries and prevent dangerous climate change. CDP enables businesses to report on their climate, water and deforestation impacts.
WDI (Workforce Disclosure Initiative)
Launched in 2016, WDI collects data from companies on how they manage both employees and people working in their supply chain.
Authors
Related
Don’t be a mixed-up chameleon! How to prioritize your ESG issues
Making materiality the cornerstone of your sustainability strategy will help you to prioritize ESG issues to ensure they drive a business strategy that benefits both your organization and society...
Carrots and sticks needed to speed up the green business transformation
Government incentives to promote green technology and collaboration between startups and established companies will help accelerate the transformation to net zero, experts said in the latest Business Schools for Climate Leadership webinar....
ESG guidelines seem innocuous enough, so why the backlash?
Environmental, social and governance measures have become a central battleground over the purpose of a corporation and who gets to exercise control. ...
Audio available
Audio availableLearn Brain Circuits
Join us for daily exercises focusing on issues from team building to developing an actionable sustainability plan to personal development. Go on - they only take five minutes.
Explore Leadership
What makes a great leader? Do you need charisma? How do you inspire your team? Our experts offer actionable insights through first-person narratives, behind-the-scenes interviews and The Help Desk.
Join Membership
Log in here to join in the conversation with the I by IMD community. Your subscription grants you access to the quarterly magazine plus daily articles, videos, podcasts and learning exercises.